The Tom Prettys: A Fresh Take on Tom Petty’s Music and Legacy

Tom Petty’s songs have long lived in the American rock bloodstream — built on heartland storytelling, sharp hooks, and an easygoing sense of both nostalgia and rebellion. This weekend, fans in the region will hear those classics again in a new setting, as the tribute band The Tom Prettys brings the catalog to life at the Bearsville Theater.

The group doesn’t aim to impersonate Petty so much as channel the spirit of the songs — treating them as living pieces of rock history rather than museum artifacts.

Members Dana Page and Larry Hart described a project built around shared admiration for Petty’s songwriting, and a desire to keep the music accessible across generations.

The band itself has evolved over time. Page explained that it began in a different configuration before settling into its current form.

“We’ve been around in different iterations for about seven years,” Page said. “And initially, we were actually all girls and we we invited some men into the band somewhat recently, which was a fabulous decision.”

Larry Hart said he entered the project through an existing musical friendship, after being invited to join by Page and others.

“I am one of those said guys that was brought in,” Hart said. “I’m a New Jersey guy and they came down to see me play in another band and we formed… I’m also in another Tom Petty tribute band. So we have this shared love and affection of Tom Petty and Heartbreakers. So to ask me to join was kind of natural and easy because we were friends as well.”

For Hart, Petty’s enduring appeal comes down to craftsmanship — songs that feel instantly recognizable even on first listen.

“It’s just a hook, it’s something,” Hart said when discussing what makes the music resonate. He added later, “He’s a great songwriter. That’s the bottom line. He’s a great rock and roll pop songwriter. End of the story.”

Page and Hart also pointed to the generational reach of Petty’s music — its ability to land with listeners across age groups and backgrounds.

Hart said, “I could play Tom Petty’s music in front of 20-year-olds and 70-year-olds, and it speaks to like the American growing up experience with every part of an aspect of your life as you go through phases as a young kid, as an adult, and they all ring true to like every experience that we we have as people.”

Unlike some tribute acts that lean heavily into visual imitation, The Tom Prettys emphasize interpretation and performance.

Page said her role as a woman fronting Petty’s music naturally shapes the band’s approach.

“I think because I’m a woman doing Tom Petty music, it’s really almost impossible for me to impersonate him,” she said. “So that right away gives me liberty to kind of do my own spin.”

Hart echoed that philosophy, drawing a distinction between performance and costume.

“It ends up being seen a lot of tribute bands that it almost looks like a costume party rather than a rock and roll show,” he said. “And I think what Tom Petty always wanted to do is put on an awesome rock and roll show. And that’s what we do.”

Image Credit: The Tom Prettys